The Blanket

The Blanket - A Journal of Protest & Dissent

Shoot to Kill: Getting Away with State Murder

Eamonn McCann • 31 July 2005

Many people in Northern Ireland nodded in recognition when they heard of Jean Charles de Menezes being shot repeatedly in the head as he lay face-down and helpless on the floor of a tube train at Stockwell.

They will have recalled Sean Savage, an unarmed member of the IRA, shot 16 times at point-blank range by plain-clothes members of the SAS in Gibraltar in March 1998 after he‘d put his hands up in surrender. The SAS immediately claimed, and most of the media reported as fact, that they’d believed he’d been about to trigger a bomb. Two other unarmed IRA members were gunned down on the same occasion.

Although the European Court of Human Rights later found the killings unlawful, no action was ever taken against the killers.

18-year old Peter McBride was unarmed, inoffensive and a member of no political or paramilitary organisation, walking home one night in north Belfast in September 1992, when two members of the Scots Guards, Fisher and Wright, chased him along the street before taking aim and shooting him in the back. They said he’d made a “sudden movement” and might have been intent on throwing a “coffee-jar bomb.”

Their commanding officer, Col. Tim Spicer, told an army board later that if he’d had his way the killers would have been commended, given back their rifles and sent out to complete their patrol.

After a huge outcry in Northern Ireland, Fisher and Wright Fisher were charged and convicted of murder. Both were released on the orders of Mo Mowlam after serving two years and taken back into their regiment, with back pay restored. Fisher has since been promoted. The pair are now believed to be serving in Basra.

Their commander, Spicer, now heads the private security company Aegis, employing mainly ex-soldiers, which has just won a $293 million contract from the Pentagon to provide “specialist security personnel and expertise” in Iraq.

Kevin McGovern, 19, a student at an agricultural college, was on his way to a disco in Cookstown, Co. Tyrone in September 1991, carrying a can of beer, when a RUC man shot him in the back. The cops claimed that when challenged by a patrol, he “took up the standard aiming stance for a pistol-revolver.” A policeman charged with murder was acquitted: the judge found that although his actions were unreasonable, his belief in that the teenager might have been about to shoot him was not! The killer was reinstated in the police.

In the course of the Northern conflict, police and soldiers have killed 357 people, About 150 of these were members of Republican paramilitary organisations, not all of whom were armed at the time. 189 of the victims were unarmed civilians. The Scots Guards are the only individuals with murder convictions as a result of these deaths.

Families and friends of the dead have faced formidable difficulties in seeking the truth.

There’s the unwillingness or inability of the political and judicial establishment to accept that the State condones not just trigger-happy police and soldiers and occasionally irresponsible behaviour, but deliberate murder. They shut their minds against the possibility. Or rather, against admission of the possibility.

There’s the notion of no smoke without fire, that for all the apparent innocence of the victim, he or she must have said or done something to “send out the wrong signal” and attract the lethal attentions of the killers.

There’s the operation of deep-set prejudice against the category of people from the whom the victim is most likely to come. In the North, for example, 86 percent of non-paramilitary civilian victims of State killings in the last 30 years have been Catholics.

And there’s the fact that the media and other more subtle manipulators of opinion will set out deliberately to ensure that a false account is first into the public domain and therefore likely to overshadow the truth when and if it eventually emerges.

Most important, perhaps, is the insidious idea that, whatever the truth of a particular incident, to make much of it is to “play into the hands of the terrorists.” There’s a risk of drawing down the wrath of the State onto oneself---undergoing the same demonisation and marginalisation which may have played a part in the killing in the first place.

As a result, many who will speak up after a State killing for human rights and against State excess will take care to explain that they are not blaming the State generally or challenging the right of the State to use lethal force to “protect the public.” They just want reassurance things were done properly in this instance. Or if not, that the “mistake” will be noted, “lessons learned.”

They balk at the plain obvious truth of killings like the killing of Jean Charles de Menezess because the implication of the truth is that State forces routinely kill innocent citizens and routinely get away with it and that any working-class person who puts trust in the police or army is a fool.








Index: Current Articles + Latest News and Views + Book Reviews + Letters + Archives

The Blanket - A Journal of Protest & Dissent



All censorships exist to prevent any one from challenging current conceptions and existing institutions. All progress is initiated by challenging current conceptions, and executed by supplanting existing institutions. Consequently the first condition of progress is the removal of censorships.
- George Bernard Shaw

Index: Current Articles

1 August 2005

Other Articles From This Issue:

An Open Letter to Gerry Adams
Dolours Price

The Inevitable
Anthony McIntyre

PIRA Statement 'Neither Surprising nor Historic'
32 County Sovereignty Movement

'Provisional IRA Should Disband Completely'
Ruairí Ó Brádaigh

A Momentous, Historic, Courageous and Confident Statement
Jimmy Sands

When History Was Made
Brian Mór

Roundup on the IRA Statement
Liam O Ruairc

The Way of the Apache and Lakota
Eoghan O'Suilleabhain

Strange Bedfellows?
Eamonn McCann

Rewriting the Past to Suit the Present
Mick Hall

Shoot to Kill: Getting Away with State Murder
Eamonn McCann

Parents of the World Unite
Fred A Wilcox

31 May 2005

Justice is the Right of All Our Victims
Gemma McCartney

Quis Separabit? The Short Strand/Markets UDA
Anthony McIntyre

Civil Law as an Instrument of Resistance
Peter Mason

A Salute to Comrades
Dolours Price

Behaviour of Young Gets Worse
David Adams

Recognising Similarities, Delivering for the People
Mick Hall

One Republican Party
Dr John Coulter

Venezuela: A Common Brotherhood
Tomas Gorman

May Day versus Loyalty Day
Mary La Rosa

One Eyed Morality
Anthony McIntyre

Lying in Wait for the Dutch Tsunami…After the French Earthquake

Michael Youlton



The Blanket




Latest News & Views
Index: Current Articles
Book Reviews
The Blanket Magazine Winter 2002
Republican Voices